At 154 E. 17th St., the cases are full of fish again. Bear Flag Fish Co. opened in the former Santa Monica Seafood space, with a fresh-seafood market, counter service, a sushi bar, a full bar, and seating inside and on the patio, as reported by OCfoodies on Oct. 27. The company's own locations page now lists the Costa Mesa store as "NOW OPEN."
It's one of the few new things on East 17th Street this year that looks like what it replaced. Over 2026, the street lost a 65-year-old bottle shop, a 21-and-over supper club and an upscale Mexican restaurant from its 2018 class. The leases that followed went to a bagel franchise, a sandwich chain, a family-run Mediterranean group with a 1987 flagship in Tustin, and a Los Angeles grocer. The pattern runs one way. Long-running independents and late-night spots are giving way to daytime, all-ages food from brands that already operate somewhere else.
The Seafood Address Kept Its Seafood
Santa Monica Seafood closed its Costa Mesa market and cafe in February 2025 after nearly three decades. It cited a hard operating climate for U.S. restaurants, according to Hoodline's summary of SeafoodSource reporting. Bear Flag filed development plans for the site in October 2025. The company was founded in 2007 by fisherman Thomas Carson.
The new store adds a fourth Orange County Bear Flag to the ones on the Newport Peninsula, at Crystal Cove and in Huntington Beach. So a corner that spent decades as a seafood market stays one, now under a Newport Beach-born brand that already runs a restaurant on the Peninsula. On this street in 2026, that counts as the continuity case.
Address by Address, as of Early November 2026
Here's the 17th Street turnover in one view. "Status" means what the most recent source says as of this week, not a promise from the operator.
| Address | Previous tenant | What's next | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 140 E. 17th St. | T-Shirts Warehouse | Erewhon | Lease signed; debut targeted for September 2027 |
| 154 E. 17th St. | Santa Monica Seafood | Bear Flag Fish Co. | Open, reported Oct. 27, 2026 |
| 299 E. 17th St. | Not reported | Sourdough & Co. | Listed as "coming soon," no date |
| 333 E. 17th St., Suite 21 | Not reported | PopUp Bagels | Plans pending city review |
| 428 E. 17th St. | Playa Mesa | Zov's | Opening scheduled for late 2026 |
| 436 E. 17th St. | Wild Goose Tavern | No change | Open |
| 17th Street, former Pierce Street Annex building | The Country Club | All-ages concept, no name given in May | Closed since May 10, 2026 |
The 400 block is where the evening and late-night spots were, and it's where the changes hit hardest.
The 400 Block Lost Its Late-Night Room First
The Country Club went first. For years it ran as a scratch kitchen with craft cocktails, live music and a strict 21-plus door. Its owners announced they would close and rebuild as a family-friendly venue, Back Bay Buzz reported in May. Their reason was specific. The building's historic liquor license limited the clientele to adults 21 and over, and that no longer fit their plans, so they are moving to an all-ages license. Final service was Mother's Day, May 10.
The building has more history behind it than one remodel. Before The Country Club, the A-frame housed the Pierce Street Annex for decades, which Back Bay Buzz calls one of Orange County's oldest drinking and entertainment establishments. The Country Club's remodel kept that A-frame roofline. In May the owners called the closure "a pause as we prepare for what's next." The May announcement gave no name or opening date for the new concept, and the venue's website still says "Closed."
Playa Mesa closed next. Its owners announced the closure Aug. 1 without giving a reason, according to the Orange County Register. The restaurant opened at 428 E. 17th St. in July 2018, as OC Weekly reported at the time. Both venues belonged to Newport Beach's Lounge Group, founded by Mario Marovic and Andrew Gabriel. The group's coastal lineup also includes High Horse Saloon, Madero 1899, Stag Bar + Kitchen and Blackie's By The Sea.
Lounge Group hasn't left the block, though. Wild Goose Tavern, its concept next door to the old Playa Mesa, is still open at 436 E. 17th St. And the operator moving into Playa Mesa's space fits the same daytime, family-table direction as the Country Club conversion.
Who Is Signing Leases Instead
Zov's is the most immediate. The Mediterranean-inspired group is putting its fifth Orange County location at 428 E. 17th St., scheduled for late 2026, per the Orange County Business Journal. Chef Zov Karamardian founded it in 1987, and three generations of the Karamardian family now run it. Its other restaurants are in Tustin, Irvine, Newport Coast and San Clemente. Zov's held hiring events for the Costa Mesa store on Oct. 14, 17, 21 and 24, recruiting hosts, servers, bartenders, cooks and managers. No opening day has been announced.
PopUp Bagels filed plans for Suite 21 at 333 E. 17th St. Those plans were pending review and approval as of WhatNow's Oct. 26 report. If approved, it would be the first Orange County location of the Connecticut-founded franchise, which serves its bagels hot and whole rather than sliced. A franchise group signed an agreement in April 2025 to develop 25 PopUp locations across Southern California. The center calls itself 333 East and has been on 17th Street since 1962.
Sourdough & Co. lists its Costa Mesa store at 299 E. 17th St. as "coming soon," with no date.
Erewhon is the furthest out. The grocer signed a lease for a 20,092-square-foot former warehouse at 140 E. 17th St., Hoodline reported, and it will be the chain's first Orange County store. In May, the Register noted that Erewhon's website gave September 2027 for the debut. That puts the store next door to the new Bear Flag.
The independent that left with the least notice was Baycrest Caps & Corks at 333 East. The 65-year-old bottle shop closed in spring 2026 when its lease wasn't renewed, even though the shop offered 20% above the asking rent, according to Hoodline. 333 East's online directory still lists Baycrest among its open businesses, so treat that list as out of date.
Every incoming name already runs locations somewhere else, and none of them is built around late nights or an adults-only door. Bear Flag comes from the Peninsula, Zov's from Tustin, PopUp Bagels from Connecticut by way of a Southern California franchise group, and Erewhon from Los Angeles.
What to Expect, in Order
Here is how the street's calendar lines up:
- Now: Bear Flag Fish Co. at 154 E. 17th St. is open for market shopping, tacos, sushi and the bar.
- Late 2026: Zov's at 428 E. 17th St., with hiring done in October and no day announced yet.
- No date yet: Sourdough & Co. at 299 E. 17th St. is "coming soon," PopUp Bagels at 333 East is waiting on city approval, and the all-ages successor to The Country Club had no name or date when it was announced in May.
- September 2027: Erewhon at 140 E. 17th St., per the company's target as reported in May.
Wild Goose Tavern at 436 E. 17th St. is the one 400-block address from the start of 2026 that is still pouring under the same name.
If you own a home within walking distance of 17th Street and want to know how buyers are weighing a corridor with Bear Flag open, Zov's on the way and Erewhon slated for 2027, the Teicheira Team can walk you through it. Request a Home Valuation or Auction Consultation and we'll start with your street.